Skip to the lesson

Engineering designLesson 5 of 6

Part 1 of 3, 0 done

14 min

What went wrong? Reading a failure

A NASA spacecraft flew to Mars for nine months and was lost in minutes, because one team's file used pounds and another expected newtons. Nobody was careless on purpose. So what really failed?

Ticket 01 · The guess

How low did it go?

NASA's Mars Climate Orbiter was aimed to pass 226 kmnasa.gov ·1999 above Mars on arrival, in September 1999. Below about 80 kmnasa.gov ·1999, it could not survive. How low did it actually go?

150 km
0 km300 km
Words to know

Spot something wrong?

Tell us what looks off. No name or email needed.

What kind of problem?

0 / 1000

We'll also send this page, the lesson, ticket 1, so we can find it. Nothing else. Privacy

·
Sources and every number (1)

Sources

  • Mars Climate Orbiter Mishap Investigation Board Phase I Report · NASA, 1999

Every number

  • 226 kmnasa.gov ·1999 · The planned first closest approach to Mars after the last course correction, in the board's Phase I report.
  • 80 kmnasa.gov ·1999 · The lowest closest approach the orbiter was considered able to survive, in the Phase I report.
  • 57 kmnasa.gov ·1999 · The after-the-fact estimate of the orbiter's first closest approach, in the Phase I report.
  1. Lessons›
  2. The school›
  3. Engineering design
  • ·Before this: How strong is strong enough?
  • ·Next: Change one part, change everything
Skip to the lesson

Engineering designLesson 5 of 6

Part 1 of 3, 0 done

14 min

What went wrong? Reading a failure

A NASA spacecraft flew to Mars for nine months and was lost in minutes, because one team's file used pounds and another expected newtons. Nobody was careless on purpose. So what really failed?

Ticket 01 · The guess

How low did it go?

NASA's Mars Climate Orbiter was aimed to pass 226 kmnasa.gov ·1999 above Mars on arrival, in September 1999. Below about 80 kmnasa.gov ·1999, it could not survive. How low did it actually go?

150 km
0 km300 km
Words to know

Spot something wrong?

Tell us what looks off. No name or email needed.

What kind of problem?

0 / 1000

We'll also send this page, the lesson, ticket 1, so we can find it. Nothing else. Privacy

·
Sources and every number (1)

Sources

  • Mars Climate Orbiter Mishap Investigation Board Phase I Report · NASA, 1999

Every number

  • 226 kmnasa.gov ·1999 · The planned first closest approach to Mars after the last course correction, in the board's Phase I report.
  • 80 kmnasa.gov ·1999 · The lowest closest approach the orbiter was considered able to survive, in the Phase I report.
  • 57 kmnasa.gov ·1999 · The after-the-fact estimate of the orbiter's first closest approach, in the Phase I report.
  1. Lessons›
  2. The school›
  3. Engineering design
  • ·Before this: How strong is strong enough?
  • ·Next: Change one part, change everything